Advertisement
The Coconut Grove Playhouse project is moving forward with new neighborhood protections aimed at balancing the return of the historic theater with residents’ concerns.
The Miami City Commission last week granted Miami-Dade County’s appeal of zoning waivers needed to advance the Coconut Grove Playhouse redevelopment, clearing a major hurdle after years of delays and litigation. The approval allows the county to restore the historic theater, construct a new performance venue and add supporting uses while requiring additional commitments tied to traffic, neighborhood protections and preservation of the West Grove’s cultural identity.
The Coconut Grove Playhouse has remained closed since 2006, when the theater shut down in bankruptcy, leaving one of South Florida’s most recognizable cultural landmarks vacant for nearly two decades. Since then, efforts to revive the site have been shaped by competing priorities: restoring a historic performing arts venue, creating a financially sustainable operation, and protecting the character of the historic West Grove community nearby.
Miami-Dade Commissioner Raquel Regalado said the county began reworking plans for the site in 2008 through a series of community charrettes that helped shape the current proposal. The county received approvals from the city in 2018, but the project stalled in years of litigation involving property issues and other disputes.
Ms. Regalado said the county ultimately chose to return to the city’s approval process rather than continue fighting in court. She emphasized that Miami-Dade County is fully funding the project and is not seeking a financial contribution from the city.
For Ms. Regalado, the project represents more than a construction effort – it represents the return of a cultural institution that has been unavailable to an entire generation. “I grew up going to the Coconut Playhouse, as many of you did,” she said. “Unfortunately, my children, who are 21 and 22, have never been inside. We deprived an entire generation access to this amazing establishment.”
The approved plan would restore the Playhouse’s historic 1926 façade while constructing a new theater behind it with roughly 310 seats. The redevelopment also includes a 289-space parking garage and additional supporting uses, including about 2,600 square feet for retail, 3,800 square feet of food and beverage space, 28,000 square feet for offices and 2,600 square feet of educational space.
Those commercial components became a central point of debate during last week’s hearing.
Nearby residents argued they support bringing the theater back but raised concerns about increased traffic, noise, parking pressures and the potential impact of commercial activity on the West Grove. Attorney David Winker, representing several nearby residents, urged commissioners to reject the appeal, arguing the county should pursue a zoning change rather than receive waivers.
“This is a civic use space. This is public space,” Mr. Winker said, arguing the project would significantly alter the property’s existing character. “They can do that, but they need to go through a change of zoning.”
Mr. Winker also criticized the lack of a completed traffic study before approval and raised concerns about requested waivers that would increase lot coverage, reduce required green space and expand permitted paving areas.
County officials disputed the characterization of the project as primarily commercial, saying some uses are necessary to make the restored theater financially sustainable. Ms. Regalado said the county is partnering with the Miami Parking Authority on the parking and that the theater itself remains a civic and cultural project.
Commissioner Damian Pardo, whose district includes Coconut Grove, said the project has been one of the community’s most contentious issues for decades but residents ultimately wanted a path forward after years of conflict.
“When you hear that this is a big commercial thing, it’s just not,” Mr. Pardo said. “The biggest commercial piece is parking, and then you have a theater which is being restored, which the community wants to see happen again in Coconut Grove.”
To address neighborhood concerns, Mr. Pardo attached several conditions to the approval, including a requirement that no commercial frontage face the Little Bahamas/West Grove single-family neighborhood, a buffer between the project and surrounding homes, a traffic study and mitigation plan developed with residents, workforce opportunities, access for historic churches and community organizations, and continued investment in recognizing Little Bahamas’ history and landmarks.
Ms. Regalado said the county also agreed to added neighborhood protections, including buffering along the rear of the property and a gate along a pedestrian connection to prevent event activity from spilling into nearby streets. Commissioners said the redevelopment would improve current conditions at a largely vacant site, adding landscaping and trees while restoring a long-closed cultural venue.
The commission unanimously approved the appeal with the added conditions, allowing Miami-Dade County to move the Playhouse restoration forward.
County officials and city leaders said coordination with residents will remain part of the process as the project advances, with traffic, neighborhood protections and community benefits shaping the next phase of the redevelopment.
